South Lyon MI Real Estate Guide: Best Neighborhoods for Families 2026
Downtown South Lyon Halloween Trick or Treat
South Lyon MI Real Estate Guide: Best Neighborhoods for Families 2026
If you're searching for that sweet spot between small-town charm and modern convenience, South Lyon deserves a serious look. As someone who lives in this community and helps families find homes here, I can tell you that South Lyon offers something increasingly rare in Metro Detroit—space to breathe, a genuine downtown, and neighborhoods where kids still ride bikes to their friends' houses.
But here's what most people don't realize until they start house hunting: South Lyon isn't just one community. It spans the City of South Lyon, Lyon Township, and parts of Green Oak Township, each with different price points, lot sizes, and vibes. Choosing the right area makes all the difference in your daily life.
This guide breaks down everything you need to know about South Lyon real estate, from the walkable streets near downtown to the sprawling estates with acreage on the outskirts.
Why Families Are Choosing South Lyon
Kensington Metropark Nature Center
Before we dive into specific neighborhoods, let's talk about what draws people here. When I ask my clients why they chose South Lyon over Northville, Novi, or Brighton, the answers are remarkably consistent.
More house for your money. This is the big one. The average home value in South Lyon sits around $471,000—and for that price, you're getting significantly more square footage and land than you'd find in Northville or Novi. Families priced out of those markets often find exactly what they want here.
The small-town feel is real. South Lyon's downtown isn't manufactured charm—it's genuine. The South Lyon Hotel has been feeding locals since 1867. The annual Pumpkinfest draws thousands every October. Friday night football games feel like community events because they are. This is a place where people actually know their neighbors.
Space and nature. Kensington Metropark sits right at your doorstep. The Huron Valley Rail Trail offers 12 miles of paved paths connecting South Lyon to Wixom and beyond. Unlike the more developed suburbs to the east, you can still find properties with acreage here—actual land for gardens, horses, or just privacy.
Location without the chaos. I-96 is just four miles north, putting you 40 miles from downtown Detroit. M-59 and US-23 are equally accessible. You get suburban convenience without sitting in Novi traffic or navigating the congestion around Twelve Oaks Mall.
South Lyon Community Schools: What Parents Need to Know
South Lyon East High School Campus
Schools drive real estate decisions in South Lyon, so let's cover this thoroughly.
South Lyon Community Schools serves over 8,400 students across 12 schools and consistently ranks in the top 10% of Michigan districts. Both South Lyon High School and South Lyon East High School rank in the top 100 high schools statewide, with graduation rates above 90% and strong AP participation.
Elementary Schools: The district operates eight elementary schools, with Millennium Middle School and William A. Pearson Elementary standing out as magnet schools with particularly strong test scores. Hardy Elementary, Bartlett Elementary, Dolsen Elementary, and Sayre Elementary all maintain solid reputations, with most rated B+ or higher.
Middle Schools: Millennium Middle School ranks among the top 100 middle schools in Michigan. Centennial Middle School serves the South Lyon East attendance area and maintains strong academics.
High Schools: Here's where it gets interesting. South Lyon has two high schools—South Lyon High School (the original) and South Lyon East High School (opened 2008). Both are excellent, but they draw from different areas and have slightly different cultures. South Lyon High feels more established with deeper athletic traditions. South Lyon East has a newer facility and growing programs. Your neighborhood determines which high school your kids attend.
One thing to note: Some areas near South Lyon feed into different districts entirely—Brighton, Huron Valley, or Northville. Before falling in love with a property, verify the school district. I've had clients assume a South Lyon address meant South Lyon schools, only to discover the home was actually in Brighton district.
South Lyon's Best Neighborhoods: A Complete Breakdown
Downtown South Lyon
Price Range: $350,000 - $650,000+
Home Styles: Historic Bungalows, Colonials, Updated Ranches
Lot Sizes: 0.15 - 0.35 acres
Best For: Walkability, community connection, starter luxury homes
Living in downtown South Lyon means you can walk to restaurants, shops, and community events. Grab coffee at Biggby, lunch at Lyon's Den, dinner at the South Lyon Hotel. The Witch's Hat Depot museum is around the corner. Pumpkinfest happens in your backyard.
Witch’s Hat Depot Museum, McHattie Park
The trade-off? Smaller lots and homes that often need updating. Many downtown properties were built in the 1920s through 1960s, meaning character and charm but also potential projects. That said, updated homes in downtown South Lyon command strong prices because the location is irreplaceable.
What I tell buyers: If walkability and community matter more than square footage, downtown delivers. You'll sacrifice space but gain convenience and connection.
Tanglewood
Price Range: $650,000 - $1,000,000
Home Styles: Colonials, Two-Stories, Contemporary
Lot Sizes: 0.25 - 0.5 acres
Best For: Established families, move-in ready homes, neighborhood feel
Tanglewood is one of South Lyon's most established and desirable subdivisions. Built primarily in the 1990s and 2000s, homes here offer that sweet spot of newer construction without the premium of brand-new builds. Tree-lined streets, golf course views, sidewalks throughout, and an active homeowner association create genuine neighborhood character.
Homes typically range from 2,000 to 3,500 square feet with three to five bedrooms. You'll find finished basements, updated kitchens, and well-maintained landscaping. The neighborhood feeds into highly-rated schools and sits close to downtown without being in the thick of it.
What I tell buyers: Tanglewood sells quickly when homes come available. If you want an established neighborhood on a golf course, with mature trees and proven home values, put this on your list.
Carriage Club
Price Range: $500,000 - $800,000
Home Styles: Colonials, Custom Builds
Lot Sizes: 0.3 - 0.75 acres
Best For: Executives, growing families, upgrade buyers
Carriage Club represents South Lyon's move-up market. Larger lots, higher-end finishes, and homes that feel substantial without the million-dollar price tags you'd find in Northville's Stonewater or Edenderry.
Expect 2,500 to 4,500 square feet, gourmet kitchens, first-floor master suites in some floor plans, and generous outdoor space. The neighborhood maintains a prestigious feel while remaining accessible to buyers who want luxury without the extreme price point.
What I tell buyers: This is where South Lyon competes directly with Northville and Novi's nicer subdivisions—but at 15-20% less per square foot. Value-conscious buyers who want quality without overpaying land here.
Lyon Ridge and Lyon Trail
Price Range: $400,000 - $600,000
Home Styles: Newer Construction, Traditional Two-Stories
Lot Sizes: 0.2 - 0.4 acres
Best For: Young families, first-time move-up buyers, modern floor plans
These newer developments offer contemporary floor plans with open concepts, modern kitchens, and energy-efficient construction. Built within the last 10-15 years, homes here require less immediate updating than older neighborhoods.
You'll find popular builders and consistent quality throughout. The neighborhoods attract families with young children who want newer homes without venturing too far from established amenities.
What I tell buyers: If you want turnkey and modern without custom-build prices, these subdivisions deliver. Less character than older neighborhoods but more predictable quality.
Eagle Heights & The Knolls
Price Range: $550,000 - $850,000
Home Styles: Custom Colonials, Walkout Ranches, Contemporary
Lot Sizes: 0.5 - 1.5 acres
Best For: Privacy seekers, executives, buyers wanting space
These premium subdivisions offer what many buyers can't find in more developed areas—actual land. Half-acre to one-acre-plus lots provide breathing room, privacy, and space for outdoor living that's increasingly rare in Metro Detroit.
Homes range from 3,000 to 5,000+ square feet with high-end finishes, three-car garages, and the kind of details that distinguish custom builds from production homes. Walkout basements are common given the rolling topography.
What I tell buyers: This is South Lyon's luxury segment. You're getting Northville-quality homes with more land at lower prices. The compromise is slightly longer drives to everything.
Arbors of Lyon / New Hudson Area
Price Range: $350,000 - $550,000
Home Styles: Newer Construction, Ranches, Two-Stories
Lot Sizes: 0.25 - 0.35 acres
Best For: Budget-conscious families, first-time buyers, new construction seekers
The New Hudson area (technically Lyon Township) offers some of the most affordable newer construction in the South Lyon school district. Proximity to Kensington Metropark and Island Lake Recreation Area adds outdoor recreation value.
Arbors of Lyon specifically features 1/3-acre lots with ranch, two-story, and colonial floor plans ranging from 1,700 to 3,000 square feet. These neighborhoods attract buyers who want South Lyon schools without South Lyon prices.
What I tell buyers: If budget matters more than prestige, the New Hudson area delivers genuine value. You're trading neighborhood cachet for affordability and newer construction.
Rural Lyon Township (Acreage Properties)
Price Range: $500,000 - $1.2M+
Home Styles: Custom Estates, Farmhouses, Horse Properties
Lot Sizes: 2 - 20+ acres
Best For: Horse owners, hobby farmers, ultimate privacy seekers
The outskirts of Lyon Township still offer something increasingly rare—actual acreage. Properties with 5, 10, even 20+ acres come available for buyers wanting space that simply doesn't exist in more developed suburbs.
These aren't cookie-cutter homes. You'll find custom builds, renovated farmhouses, and equestrian properties with barns and pastures. Zoning allows for horses, chickens, and other livestock in many areas.
What I tell buyers: If you've dreamed of land—real land—this might be your only chance in the Metro Detroit area. Properties like these become rarer every year as development pushes outward.
What Your Budget Gets You in South Lyon
Understanding price points helps set realistic expectations:
$350,000 - $450,000: Entry-level homes in South Lyon. Expect 1,500-2,200 square feet, three to four bedrooms, possibly dated kitchens and baths. Downtown locations or older subdivisions. Condos and townhomes also fall in this range.
$450,000 - $600,000: The sweet spot for most families. You're looking at 2,000-3,000 square feet, four bedrooms, updated or original-owner condition, quarter to half-acre lots. This range delivers the most options and the fastest sales.
$600,000 - $800,000: Move-up territory. Homes here offer 3,000-4,000 square feet, premium finishes, larger lots, and desirable subdivision locations. First-floor master suites, finished basements, and three-car garages become common.
$800,000+: Luxury market. Custom builds, golf course views, significant acreage, or premium locations with exceptional finishes. Properties at this level compete directly with Northville and Brighton's high-end markets.
Living in South Lyon: Beyond the House
Your home matters, but so does daily life. Here's what living in South Lyon actually looks like.
The commute reality. I-96 sits four miles north, making commutes to Novi, Farmington Hills, or Livonia straightforward. Ann Arbor runs about 25 minutes via US-23. Downtown Detroit is 40-45 miles but accessible via I-96 or M-14. Many South Lyon residents work remotely at least partially, making the location even more attractive.
Downtown dining and options. The South Lyon Hotel serves classic American fare in a historic setting. Witch's Hat Brewing Company pours craft beer made locally. The Corner Social brings upscale casual dining. The options have grown significantly in recent years, though this isn't Northville's restaurant density.
Recreation everywhere. Kensington Metropark provides 4,500 acres of trails, beaches, disc golf, and nature. The Huron Valley Rail Trail connects communities via 12 miles of paved paths. McHattie Park offers sledding in winter and a popular splash pad in summer. Golf courses dot the area. For outdoors-focused families, South Lyon delivers.
Community events. Pumpkinfest draws 75,000+ visitors every October—it's one of Michigan's largest family festivals. Summer concerts happen in downtown's park. The farmers market runs weekly during growing season. Holiday parades, art fairs, and community celebrations fill the calendar.
South Lyon Pumpkinfest 2025
The people factor. South Lyon attracts residents who deliberately choose community over convenience. They're involved in schools, they support local businesses, and they stay long-term. You'll know your neighbors here.
South Lyon vs. Other Metro Detroit Communities
How does South Lyon compare to similar options?
South Lyon vs. Northville: Northville offers a more developed downtown, slightly higher-ranked schools, and greater prestige. Northville homes cost 15-25% more for comparable size. South Lyon delivers more land and newer construction options at lower prices. If walkable downtown matters most, Northville wins. If value and space matter more, South Lyon competes strongly.
South Lyon vs. Novi: Novi provides shopping convenience (Twelve Oaks Mall, endless retail) and newer corporate development. South Lyon offers genuine small-town character Novi can't replicate. Schools are comparable. Homes in South Lyon provide more land per dollar. Novi works better for families who prioritize shopping and restaurants; South Lyon for those wanting community and space.
South Lyon vs. Brighton: Brighton offers lake access and similar small-town atmosphere but sits farther from Detroit employment centers. Home prices are comparable, with Brighton sometimes running slightly higher for lakefront properties. Both offer excellent schools and outdoor recreation. Brighton works better for Ann Arbor commuters; South Lyon for those working toward Detroit or Novi.
South Lyon vs. Milford: Milford and South Lyon share similar small-town vibes and outdoor access. Milford's downtown is arguably more charming, with better restaurants and shops. Home prices are comparable. Milford feeds into Huron Valley Schools (also excellent). The choice often comes down to which downtown feels like home.
Next Steps: Finding Your South Lyon Home
If South Lyon sounds like your community, here's what I recommend:
Define what matters most. Walkability or acreage? Newer construction or established character? Budget-conscious or move-up ready? Your priorities narrow down which neighborhoods fit.
Verify school districts carefully. South Lyon addresses don't always mean South Lyon schools. Before falling in love with a property, confirm which district it feeds into—South Lyon, Brighton, Huron Valley, or Northville all serve different parts of the greater area.
Get financially prepared. Talk with a lender who knows the local market. The median home price around $471,000 means you'll need solid financing. Property taxes in Oakland County run higher than state averages, so factor that into your monthly budget.
Drive the neighborhoods. Come on a Saturday morning when residents are out. Drive through during school pickup. Visit downtown during Pumpkinfest or a summer concert. Get a feel for daily life, not just the homes themselves.
Work with a local expert. South Lyon moves fast when good inventory comes available. Homes spend an average of just 20 days on market before going under contract. An agent who knows the community—who lives here—can help you move quickly and avoid costly mistakes.
I live in South Lyon, I raise my kids here, and I help families move into this community regularly. I know which streets flood after heavy rain, which subdivisions have active neighbors, and which homes represent genuine value versus inflated prices.
Ready to explore South Lyon? Whether you're just starting to research or ready to tour homes this weekend, I'd love to help you find your place in this community.
Frequently Asked Questions About South Lyon Real Estate
-
The average home value in South Lyon is approximately $471,000, with prices ranging from $350,000 for entry-level homes to over $1 million for luxury estates with acreage.
-
Yes. South Lyon Community Schools ranks in the top 10% of Michigan districts, with both high schools ranked in the top 100 statewide and graduation rates above 90%.
-
South Lyon offers small-town charm, excellent schools, proximity to Kensington Metropark, and more space for your money compared to Northville or Novi. It's ideal for families wanting community connection and outdoor access.
-
South Lyon is approximately 40 miles west of downtown Detroit, with easy access via I-96.
Alli Maher specializes in luxury real estate in Metro Detroit's most desirable communities, including South Lyon, Northville, Plymouth, and Novi. With an educator's heart and a realtor's expertise, she helps families navigate the home buying process with care, knowledge, and insider community connections. Contact Alli at 248-752-7989, allison@ashleyjolley.com, or visit allisonmaher.com to start your South Lyon home search.
